Jeebus, man. The same thing happened to me (new tires - woohoo).
It's way cheaper to replace the fairing lower than fix it (sanding, filling, 3 different colors + a decal).
Note that if the damage to the upper fairing is restricted to the red/white bottom part, all you need is the decal (sand the underlying plastic smooth before applying, if scratched up). The upper fairing is just blue-painted plastic and all the red&white stuff is a decal. Use the "wet method" to apply.
You can get the part# here:
Cycle Parts Nation | Arctic Cat OEM Parts | Can-Am (Bombardier) OEM Parts | Honda OEM Parts | Honda Marine OEM Parts | Honda Power Equipment OEM Parts | Kawasaki OEM Parts | Sea-Doo OEM Parts | Ski-Doo OEM Parts | Suzuki OEM Parts | Yamaha OEM Parts
Select "VFR800 2AC (07)" from the HUGE list of Honda models, go to the "Marks" section.
or use SKU 64222-MCW-K40ZA
honda code 8561508